Searching for the right feeding bottle can be challenging with so many options to consider. If you’ve started making a shortlist of potential options, then you might be wondering how AVENT vs Pigeon compares. What’s the difference between these two brands and which is better for your baby? Read on to find out!
The primary difference between Avent and Pigeon is that Avent has an anti-colic system. Avent’s Natural range also has a wide teat that’s breast-shaped to make transitioning between breast and bottle much easier. Both bottles have BPA-free plastic and heat-resistant glass options.
Avent vs Pigeon bottles – differences and similarities
When comparing these two brands, it’s important to consider the differences and similarities to make an objective decision. Some of the key features to consider are discussed below.
Material
Avent: The polypropylene material used to make Avent bottles is BPA-free and contains no toxins or harmful plastics. For parents who prefer glass, their pharmacy-grade borosilicate glass is heat and thermal shock-resistant.
Pigeon: There are two options from Pigeon. Heat-resistant glass or Poly Phenyl Sulfone (PPSU) polymer plastic. Both are BPA-free.
Nipples
Avent: The Classic range has a traditional nipple shape whereas Avent’s Natural selection features a breast-shaped nipple. This makes it easy for babies to transition between breast and bottle.
Pigeon: All Pigeon bottles feature the traditional nipple shape which makes their nipples interchangeable with all their bottles. They don’t feature a wide breast-shaped nipple. They do however boast a bottle specifically designed for babies with a cleft lip/palate. The nipple of this bottle is split to make it easier to feed babies with a cleft lip.
By the way, do you know how often you should change your bottles / nipples?
Leakage
Avent: The AVENT anti-colic bottle is prone to leaking. This could be a result of the many parts of the anti-colic system. It’s imperative to assemble these components properly to prevent leaking.
Pigeon: Since Pigeon bottles are relatively simple and have minimal components, parents report that they don’t leak.
If you’re concerned about any of your feeding bottles leaking, I recommend you read my article about the reasons why your bottles leak and what you can do about it.
Dishwasher Safe
Both brands’ bottles are dishwasher safe. Both bottle types can easily be cleaned on the top rack of the dishwasher. They can also be steamed and sterilized.
Avent bottles
The Avent brand has many different options, making it easy to find the ideal feeding bottle for your baby. Some of the more popular options include the following:
Philips AVENT Natural Baby Bottle: A natural response nipple allows the baby to breathe and swallow using their natural rhythm. The nipple is also breast-shaped to make transitioning between breast and bottle easier.
Philips AVENT Anti-Colic Baby Bottle: This bottle is designed with an anti-colic system to assist babies suffering from reflux, gas or colic. An AirFree vent keeps the nipple full of milk and not air.
Philips AVENT Glass Natural Bottle: Made from borosilicate glass this wide-necked bottle mimics the mom’s breast making transitioning between breast and bottle much easier.
Full specs of each of these bottles are available on the Philips AVENT website.
Watch this short clip to see how easy it is to assemble the AVENT Anti-Colic bottle.
Features
- Anti-colic system clinically proven to reduce colic symptoms
- Classic features a traditional nipple
- Since there are only 4 parts, it’s easy to assemble
- Airflex venting system reduces air ingestion
- Extra-soft silicone 3m+ nipples
Pros
- BPA-free
- Reputable brand
- Compatible with all Avent breast pumps & cups
- Aids babies with colic-symptoms
Cons
- Prone to leaking
Do Pigeon teats fit Avent Bottles?
Pigeon teats fit Avent Classic bottles where the teat is the same size.
Pigeon bottles
There are a few different options to consider in the Pigeon range. They’re listed below.
- Pigeon Breast Milk Heat Glass Bottle: This traditional-shaped glass bottle holds 240ml of milk. Heat-resistant glass is super-easy to keep clean and hold.
- Pigeon Breast Milking Feeding Bottle Plastic: This BPA-free plastic bottle also holds 240ml and features a smaller nipple.
- Pigeon Baby Nursing Bottle for Cleft Lip Palate Baby: Specifically designed for babies with a cleft lip or palate, this BPA-free bottle features two-sized nipples. The nipples are crosscut as well as a rectangular cut which makes it easy to feed a baby with a cleft lip. This is the same bottle that I recommend for a baby with high palate.
- Pigeon Peristaltic Plus (PPSU) Nursing Bottle: This 160ml bottle, made from PPSU is designed for newborns. It’s BPA-free and features a vented nipple.
More information on each bottle’s specifications can be found on the Pigeon website.
Features
- Made from BPA-free plastic
- Traditional nipple shape
- Holds 240ml of liquid
- Fewer parts make assembly quick and simple
- Easy to clean
Pros
- Quick assembly
- Different nipple options can easily accommodate babies with cleft lip/palate
Cons
- Traditional nipple doesn’t imitate breast shape – could be difficult to transition between breast & bottle
Do Pigeon teats fit Avent Bottles?
Pigeon teats easily fit onto the Avent classic bottles. Since Avent has wide neck bottles as well, it’s important to check the sizes of your bottles before opting to buy Pigeon teats.
Conclusion
When it comes to these two brands, my recommendation is the Avent Anti-Colic Bottle. Many parents love the Avent Natural because it’s a trusted name when it comes to dealing with colic-related issues. Its breast-shaped nipple option is great for getting babies to comfortably swap between breast and bottle. You’ll love the Avent range, and so will your baby.
If you’re still comparing options, consider reading my article comparing Comotomo to Philips Avent bottles as well as the differences between wide-neck and narrow-neck bottles. Both articles will help you make the ideal choice for your little one!
Last update on 2024-12-02 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
